Skip to content
A stack of books beside a lit table lamp

What should you sell to your audience?

Most creators start by picking a format. The format comes last. A five-step way to find the offer your audience is already asking for.

InsightsBy João RitoUpdated 7 min read

In short

Do not start with a format. Find the problem your audience asks about most, define the change you can produce for one specific kind of person, and only then choose the offer and its format.

“I should make a course” is where most creators begin. It is the last decision, not the first. A course is a container. What goes in it, and whether a course is even the right container, depends on things you have not looked at yet.

The order that works:

Audience, then problem, then transformation, then offer, then format.

Start with who is actually there

Not the audience you describe in your bio. The one that shows up.

Look at who comments, who replies to stories, who sends DMs. What stage are they at? Beginners, or people already doing the thing and stuck? What do they have in common beyond following you?

You are looking for the largest group that shares a situation. “People interested in fitness” is not a situation. “People who signed up for their first race and have twelve weeks” is.

Find the problem they keep bringing you

Your audience tells you what to sell. It is in the questions.

Here is an exercise that takes about an hour.

  1. Open your comments and DMs from the last three months.
  2. Copy every question into a single document. Do not filter.
  3. Add the questions people ask in replies to your stories.
  4. Read through and give each one a short label for the problem behind it.
  5. Count the labels.

Nearly always a small number of problems account for most of the questions. Those are your candidates.

Two more places to look. Your saved posts: the topics people keep for later are the ones they intend to act on. Your own repeated answers: whatever you have explained ten times is something people cannot easily find elsewhere.

Score the candidates

Not every common problem is worth building on. Give each candidate a score from 1 to 5 on four things.

What you are asking
Pain Do they feel it, or merely find it interesting?
Urgency Is there a reason to solve it now and not eventually?
Purchasing power Can the people who have it afford a solution?
Credibility Do they already come to you for this?

A problem that scores high on pain and low on urgency produces people who agree with you and never buy. One that scores high on everything except credibility means someone else should sell it. You want the candidate with no weak column.

Deadlines create urgency: a race, a wedding, an exam, a job application, a baby on the way. If your audience has one, build around it.

Narrow it until it is specific

Broad topics make weak offers. The useful move is from the subject you talk about to one problem for one kind of person.

Take a parenting creator. “Parenting” is a topic. Nobody buys “parenting.” Within it, though, there might be this: helping parents stay calm when their child becomes defiant. That is narrower, easier to understand, and much easier to turn into something with a beginning and an end.

The place to look is where four things overlap: a specific audience, an important problem, your expertise, and a result they want. There are usually several such places in one account. Write down three or four before choosing.

A quick test of whether it is narrow enough: could a follower read the one-line description and know immediately whether it is for them? If they would have to think about it, narrow it again.

Describe the change, not the content

Now define where the customer starts and where they finish. It helps to do this across more than one dimension.

Before After
Emotional state Reacts in the moment Can pause and respond deliberately
Fear Afraid of losing control Confident in difficult situations
Daily life Repeats the same patterns Has a different response ready
Identity “I always lose it” Sees themselves as deliberate

This table is the product. Everything you build afterwards exists to move someone from the left column to the right. If a lesson does not help with that, it does not belong.

It also stops the most common mistake, which is selling information. “Five modules on staying calm” is information. The table above is a result.

Only now, the offer and its format

With the change defined, write several versions of the offer before settling on one. The same expertise can become quite different things:

  • a 14-day intensive;
  • a 6-week mentorship;
  • an 8-week structured method.

Each has a different promise, timeline and price. Put them side by side and ask which one the audience would most plainly want, and which one you can actually deliver well.

For each version, write down six things: the name, who it is for, the promise, how long it takes, what is included, and the price. If you cannot fill in all six, the version is not finished.

Then pick the format. It follows from the problem:

  • needs a lot of personal attention: mentorship;
  • the same steps work for everyone: a recorded course;
  • small and contained: a guide or an ebook;
  • ongoing, with no finish line: a community or membership.

We go through that choice in detail in ebook, course, group program or community.

The whole thing, once through

An invented example, to show the five steps in a row.

Audience. A running coach with 30,000 followers. Most of the active ones are adults who started running in the last two years.

Problem. The most common question, by a wide margin: “I signed up for a half marathon and I do not know how to train for it without getting injured.”

Scoring. Pain: high, they are anxious. Urgency: high, there is a race date. Purchasing power: fine, they paid for race entry and shoes. Credibility: high, this is what the account is about.

Transformation. From “I do not know if I can finish” to “I crossed the line and nothing hurts.”

Offer versions. A 29 training-plan PDF. A 12-week program with a plan, strength sessions and a weekly group call. Private coaching.

Format. The PDF answers “what should I run” and not “am I doing this right”, which is the real worry. Private coaching does not scale. The 12-week program fits: a clear end, the same structure for everyone, and live time for the questions that differ.

Notice that “a course” never came up as a starting point. The format fell out of the problem.

Offers that sound good and do not sell

  • For everyone. “For anyone who wants to get healthier.” If it is for everyone, nobody recognises themselves in it.
  • A vitamin, not a painkiller. Nice to have, no reason to act now.
  • Format first. “My course” with the topic to be decided.
  • Everything you know. The complete guide to your entire subject. People want one result, not a library.
  • What you find interesting. The advanced topic you love, which your audience of beginners is not ready for.
  • A copy of someone else’s. Built because a bigger creator sells one, not because your audience asked.

Check it before you build it

A hypothesis is not an offer yet. Before recording anything:

  • describe the result in one sentence and post it. Watch the replies;
  • ask a few followers directly whether they would pay for it, and how much;
  • look at whether anyone already sells something similar. That is a good sign, not a bad one;
  • open a waiting list and see who joins.

People saying “I would buy that” is weak evidence. People joining a waiting list is stronger. People paying is the only real proof, which is why the first launch is the test. It is meant to tell you whether the audience wants this, and to give you what you need to make the second one better.

If you would rather not do this alone

This is the first part of what we do with every creator: read the audience, find the strongest opportunity, shape the offer. Then we build what sits behind it. Tell us what you make and we will tell you what we see.

Common questions

What digital product should I sell?

The one that solves the problem your audience asks you about most often. Start from the problem and the result, and let the format follow: a guide for something small, a course when the same steps work for everyone, a group program or mentorship when people need your attention.

What digital products sell the most?

There is no format that sells best everywhere. What sells is a clear result for a specific person. A well-aimed 600 program can outsell a vague 29 ebook from the same account.

Can I sell digital products on Instagram?

Yes. Instagram is where the audience is, not where the sale happens. Your content sends people to a page with a checkout, or to an application form for higher-priced offers.

How do I know if people will pay for it?

You do not, until they do. Reduce the risk before building: describe the result publicly, ask followers directly, open a waiting list. Then treat the first launch as the test.

Should I sell one product or several?

One, to begin with. A second offer makes sense once the first has sold and you know what its buyers want next.

By João Rito

Shadow Alchemy is a revenue-share growth partner for creators. We build the offer, the funnel and the launch behind your audience, and take a share of what it earns. No upfront fee. How we work

Let’s build this together

This isn’t a service, it’s a partnership.

If you have the audience, we’ll build everything that makes it pay.